10 Best Indestructible & Chew Proof Dog Collar: Buyer’s Guide & Reviews
Do you have a dog that chews just about everything in sight? If you’ve ever come home to destroyed plants, pillows, books, or furniture, you understand the frustration. Most puppies chew stuff. Fortunately, they usually grow out of the behavior…but not always.
One thing that some habitual chewers like to dig their teeth into is their collar. Whether they’re uncomfortable with the choker, or they’re just bored, the result is the same. They’ll go to extraordinary lengths to get it off.
In multi-dog households, the problem can be worse. Fido has a partner in crime who may chew up his neckband for him. Of course, this is most common with new puppies if your older dog tolerates his antics.
There are several concerns with chewed collars, and they go beyond having to replace the hardware. If your pal gnaws through his choker and escapes, he has no identification to trace back to you. Some pups also swallow the pieces, and that can mean emergency treatment or surgery.
To help put an end to this behavior, you need to figure out what’s causing the chewing. The activity often is a sign of boredom, stress, or anxiety. Unless you get to the root cause, protecting the collar may cause your pup to find something else to destroy.
While you’re getting to the bottom of things, a durable chew proof dog collar is a good temporary fix. It may not be unbreakable, but it’s tougher than the average yoke.
We evaluated 10 products to help you find the best option for your pup. But first, let’s take a look at why dogs destroy their collars and what to look for in a chew proof dog collar.
Table of Contents
Top 10 Chew-Proof Collars
Black Rhino Black Rhino - The Comfort Collar Ultra Soft
Our Ratings:
4.7/5
Price Range: $$
The Black Rhino Comfort Collar is designed to be lightweight and heavy-duty. Made with durable, soft neoprene material, that’s comfortable, odor-resistant, and weather-resistant. The band includes a layer of neoprene padding to protect your pal’s neck. It has metal fixtures.
A great feature of this collar is that it comes in a range of colors and sizes. You can pick aqua/grey, black, blue/grey, pink/black or red/black to suit your taste. Sizes can fit neck measurements from 12-26”.
If you like to go out at night with your furbaby, no problem! This product has reflective stitching for improved visibility.
- Material: Neoprene
- Available Sizes: S, M, L, X-Large
What We Like About It
- They stand up to rough dog play that includes grabbing the collar in their mouths
- The metal buckle holds up to strong pulling without breaking
- The collar provides a good fit that doesn’t slip around on the neck
- The material won’t tangle with long hair
What We Don't Like
- The padding doesn’t go all the way around the collar, and there are parts that can rub on your pal’s neck
- The logo is too big
OneTigris Military Adjustable Dog Collar
Our Ratings:
4.6/5
Price Range: $$
Made of durable nylon with a padded inner lining, the OneTigris Military collar comes in two sizes. It has sturdy, metal fixtures for extra strength. The thick band has a buckle with five adjustment points.
This product comes in five military-hues – black, coyote brown, grey, ranger green, and OD green. A fun feature for this collar is the ability to personalize your pal’s neckwear. It has a hook and loop panel where you can attach a name patch, logo, or ID information.
- Material: Nylon
- Available Sizes: M, L
What We Like About It
- It’s more reliable than a snap collar
- It’s wide enough to distribute pressure on the neck when your dog pulls on his leash
- The components are thick and durable
- It stands up well to outdoor activities and wrestling with other pooches
What We Don't Like
- The collar can rub on the neck and cause irritation
- The metal buckle can have sharp edges that may cut you or your furbaby
EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER Tactical Dog Collar
Our Ratings:
4.5/5
Price Range: $$
The Excellent Elite Spanker is a durable collar made with 1000D Nylon material. It has a double layer of fabric and a padded lining to prevent chafing and keep your pal comfortable. This band is made to hold up to daily abuse with reinforced stitching and metal hardware. The buckle has a quick-release feature that makes it easy to put on and off your special pal.
Some neat things about this collar are that it has a control grip handle to keep your furbaby close when needed and a magic sticker ID panel. You can easily attach a patch with important information to the panel. This collar comes in three sizes and four tactical colors – black, coyote brown, grey, and ranger green.
- Material: 1000D Nylon
- Available Sizes: M, L, XL
What We Like About It
- The control handle is convenient and easier to reach than a harness handle
- It’s strong and durable
- The cobra buckle holds up under pulling pressure, and dogs can’t scratch it open
- It appears to be comfortable for dogs
What We Don't Like
- The buckles have fallen apart on some collars
- It’s thick, stiff, and can be hard to put on
Tuff Pupper Heavy Duty Dog Collar with Handle
Our Ratings:
4.3/5
Price Range: $$
Built to last, the Tuff Pupper collar is made from 3-mm thick with ballistic nylon. The stainless steel buckle and D-rings are durable and secure. This collar has your dog’s comfort and safety in mind. It has a soft neoprene and a mesh lining to be gentle on Fido’s neck. The 3-M reflective trim helps you keep an eye on your pup in poor lighting and makes you more visible to drivers after dark.
This collar also features an integrated bungee handle for better control of your pooch in tight spaces. The stretchy material provides a secure yet comfortable grip. You can purchase this product in three sizes and seven attractive colors – brown, epic black, forest green, hot pink, march red, midnight blue, or steel gray.
- Material: ballistic nylon
- Available Sizes: S, ML, XL
What We Like About It
- It’s easy to clean
- It’s strong and durable
- The lining is soft and seems to be comfortable
- Dogs seem to have a hard time breaking or chewing through this collar
What We Don't Like
- The bungee handle tends to fall apart after a few months
- It’s really bulky
Yunlep Adjustable Tactical Dog Collar
Our Ratings:
4.6/5
Price Range: $$
Lightweight and durable, the Yunlep Tactical collar is made of 1000D Nylon and heavy-duty metal fixtures. It’s made to stand up to heavy use with reinforced stitching and a soft, padded inner lining that’s hypoallergenic and comfortable.
This collar features a control handle that you can use for training or keeping your furbaby close when you’re in touchy situations. Another useful aspect of this band is a magic sticker on the back. Attach a name tag, ID patch, or another velcro accessory to it. Select from three sizes and four earthy colors – black, camo, coyote brown, or ranger green.
- Material: 1000D nylon
- Available Sizes: M, L, XL
What We Like About It
- The metal buckle is heavy-duty
- It’s thick and durable
- The handle is helpful when you’re training a dog
- It appears to be comfortable
What We Don't Like
- The buckle is hard to release to get the collar off
- The control handle is on the side of the neck not on top if you attach a leash
LupinePet 3/4 Inch Adjustable Dog Collar
Our Ratings:
4.6/5
Price Range: $
This attractive LupinePet Collar is made of high-quality jacquard nylon webbing that’s designed to be durable and flexible for your pup’s comfort. It has reinforced bar tack stitching that’s used for mountain-climbing gear to provide superior strength.
You can fit this band to your pup’s neck using the nylon-plastic tri-glide adjuster. The non-slip teeth help to hold the collar in place no matter how hard your pal pulls. The side-release buckle should lay flat on your pal’s neck. This hardware is made of heavy-duty plastic that tests stronger than some metal fixtures. The leash attachment is a welded steel D-ring. With 8 colors and three adjustable sizes, you’re bound to find the right match for your pooch.
- Material: jacquard nylon
- Available Sizes: S, M, L
What We Like About It
- It’s hard for dogs to get their teeth on this collar to chew it
- They’re easy to get on and off for baths, etc.
- They have smooth edges that won’t rub against the neck
- It’s sturdy but still flexible for comfort
What We Don't Like
- The teeth in the adjuster don’t hold well if your dog pulls hard
- Some owners stated the collar dye bled into their dog’s fur
Bully's Dog Collar for Large Dogs
Our Ratings:
4.7/5
Price Range: $$
This collar is not just for pit bulls. With heavy-duty nylon lightweight, tactical materials, it’s made to be durable and functional. The hardware is made of sturdy, tarnish-resistant stainless steel. There are also a double-buckle and reinforced holes for a secure fit.
With seven adjustable neck lengths and appropriate width options, you should be able to find a suitable fit for your furbaby. The neck strap is wide for added comfort and better pressure distribution. You can pick from six colors – army green, black with red trim, fire engine red, orange juice, sapphire blue, or black with blue trim.
- Material: Heavy Duty Nylon
- Available Sizes: XS, S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL
What We Like About It
- It’s durable and stands up to heavy training use
- The strap doesn’t irritate the neck
- The buckle is very secure
- It’s thick and wide enough that it shouldn’t slip over the head
What We Don't Like
- The buckle is too thick and can leave welts
- It’s not flexible
Miles Tactical Cobra Dog Collar for Large Dogs
Our Ratings:
4.8/5
Price Range: $$
This heavy-duty collar is built to be tough and durable. It’s made of military-spec webbing and has a durable stainless steel V-ring leash attachment and adjuster slide.
A unique feature of this collar is the Austrian-made Cobra side-release buckle which is rated to withstand 4000 lbs of force. This rugged hardware is also used by NASA and our military. Another useful aspect for this product is the control handle that lets you keep your pup under wraps in tense circumstances. There’s also a velcro ID panel. The product comes in two sizes and three earthy colors – black, wolf grey, and coyote tan.
- Material:Military-spec webbing
- Available Sizes: Large, X-Large
What We Like About It
- It’s very strong and durable
- It’s well made, and the materials are high-quality
- The handle is great for controlling your dog without having to wrap your handle in the leash or collar
- The buckle works effortlessly and makes the collar easy to put on
What We Don't Like
- The sizes tend to run large
- The D-ring for ID, license, and other tags can break easily
WINSEE Harnesses with Dog Collar
Our Ratings:
4.6/5
Price Range: $$
With the WINSEE harness and collar, you get two stylish products in one affordable package. The neck strap is made of solid nylon and a lockable quick-snap buckle. It features reflective stitching, slide adjusters, and a heavy-duty D-ring leash attachment.
The no-pull harness features the same reflective stitching and fasteners for extra security. It’s made of 1680D Oxford fabric and is chew-resistant. There are front and back D-ring attachment points and a control handle on the harness.
- Material: Nylon, 1680D Oxford fabric
- Available Sizes: S, M, L, XL
What We Like About It
- The collar has thick yet comfortable material
- It has quality construction
- The reflective stitching shows up well in the dark
- The harness and collar match
What We Don't Like
- The collar clip tends to break under pressure
- The collar material is flimsy
Furbaby Products Biothane Dog Collar
Our Ratings:
4.4/5
Price Range: $$
Lightweight and durable, this heavy-duty collar features biothane-coated polyester webbing. The treatment seals the fabric and makes it stronger and more resistant to chewing and other abuses.
This attractive collar has the look and comfort of leather, and it comes in three sizes and nine color options. It’s easy to fit and has corrosion-resistant, nickel-plated hardware.
- Material: biothane coated polyester
- Available Sizes: S, M, L
What We Like About It
- The metal hardware is heavy-duty and durable
- It’s easy to adjust
- It’s easy to clean and resists odors
What We Don't Like
- It doesn’t seem to be as durable as other products
A Dog and His Collar - Why Durability Matters
Why Dogs Chew Their Collars?
There are different reasons that pooches chew on their collars or other things. Young pups often use their mouths to explore their surroundings. Hunger or teething pain can also trigger gnawing behavior. Other dogs do it because they have a natural urge to chew, and some pooches mouth objects because they’ve learned it gets your attention.
As we mentioned above, destructive chewing behavior can also be a sign of stress or anxiety. An animal that feels trapped in a confined space may chew or dig to get out, and dogs struggling with separation anxiety or other conflicts may act out by chewing.
Qualities of a Durable Chew Proof Collar
Let’s be clear here…
There’s no such thing as a completely indestructible or chew proof fabric collar.
No matter what manufacturers say, if some dogs can destroy chain-link fencing, there’s no fabric material that can stand up to a determined chewer.
That doesn’t mean you should pick a chain, however. A metal collar can be heavy, loud, and uncomfortable. It also may hurt your pal’s neck if he pulls. I don’t recommend these types of yokes.
When you shop for a collar, look for something that balances durability with comfort and proper fit. When the strap fits right and feels comfortable, your pal is more likely to leave it alone than gnaw on it. But, a collar that’s durable will last longer if your pup insists on chewing.
That’s why the desirable collar will have the following qualities:
Durable materials – Some materials, like ballistic nylon or ripstop, are more resistant to chewing while still offering a good level of comfort. There are also products with a protective coating that boosts durability.
Strong hardware – Dogs commonly target the buckles, leash attachments, or clips for chewing. Look for sturdy metal D-rings and metal buckles rather than plastic clips that can crack or break under pressure.
Comfort and Flexibility – Chew-resistant collars are often stiffer and can be less comfortable for a dog, especially if they have short hair. Some brands account for this with padding or neoprene interiors. If you’re considering a collar that combines thin metal with fabric, make sure it’s flexible and will sit against Fido’s neck comfortably.
Good Fit – Dogs are less likely to chew on collars that are comfortable. You want the neckband to fit snugly without being too tight. We’ll address tips for getting a good fit more below.
What if One Dog Chews Your Other Dog’s Collar?
If you have a chewer in a multi-dog household, he may try to gnaw on the other dog’s collar. This behavior is undesirable and unsafe. It’s important to train your pooch to find other outlets for his chewing urge. Some corrective and preventative actions you can take include:
- Apply something like bitter apple spray or another taste deterrent to the collar. These solutions give the material an unpleasant flavor that helps to repel your pup. Once you find a spicy or bitter flavor that’s effective with your pup, remember to reapply the spray periodically.
- Monitor Fido closely and immediately correct him any time he attempts to nibble his pal’s collar. It’s important to move fast so that your pup connects the correction with his behavior. Use a firm, “NO” and include a quick tap on his rump or neck if needed. If you rely on this measure, you may need to keep your pups separated when you’re not home.
- Offer attractive chew toys as a distraction. He may just be looking for something to gnaw on. Provide an alternative and praise him lavishly for nibbling the toy instead of the collar. The positive reinforcement will help him understand that this is more desirable behavior.
- Change the other dog’s collar. Get something with metal fixtures and embellishments. Canines usually avoid chewing on metal because it doesn’t feel good to them.
Quick Tips For Properly Fitting Your Dog’s Collar
Don’t rely on the “two-finger rule.” – You’ve probably heard you can check for a proper fit by slipping two fingers between the collar and your dog’s neck. The problem with that is we all have different sized fingers, so it can lead to an inconsistent fit. A better approach is to get a snug fit directly under the chin. Adjusting the collar to sit high on the neck can help to keep it out of reach of his teeth, and it avoids putting unwanted pressure on the trachea when he pulls on his leash.
Test the Collar Once It’s On – Once you have the collar properly fitted, try to slip it over your pup’s head. Remember, dogs can be Houdinis! Play with Fido’s yoke like he would to make sure he can’t get his teeth on it.
Consider Walking Your Dog With a Harness or Martingale – When you attach the leash to your pup’s collar for a walk, it puts pressure on the material. Friction and pulling can affect the fit of the collar. You’ll need to constantly check and readjust the fit. That’s why it’s best to rely on a walking harness or martingale for outings.
Check the Fit Periodically – Depending on your pup’s age and activity level, you’ll want to check the fit of his collar from time to time. Young animals may still be growing, and materials can stretch or change over time.
The Final Verdict - Our Top Pick
After reviewing the above products and comparing their features to our criteria, we pick the Miles Tactical Cobra Dog Collar as our pick for best chew proof dog collar.
This product meets all of our requirements. It’s made of military-grade webbing that’s strong, durable, and chew-resistant. The hardware is heavy-duty stainless steel for added security. It includes the safe and rugged Cobra side-release buckle.
Customers report that the collar is flexible and appears comfortable for their dogs. Bonus features include a control handle and a velcro panel where you can stick an ID patch or other important information.
